By: [email protected]

Published February 14, 2025 at 02:17 AM

State of AI (Early) 2025 - AI In A Tasteless World

A mildly unhinged rant about AI, taste, and why the internet might be turning into a giant, flavorless bowl of AI-generated oatmeal.

State of AI (early) 2025 - AI In A Tasteless World

Introduction

To start, this post is going to be pretty different from my usual, one might say much more 'meta' than 'technical' as usual. Borderline preachy maybe. Bear with me 🙏.

But the title says it all - what is 'taste' in the age of AI?

I know it sounds like a silly question but I've been thinking about it a lot and if you're reading this, odds are you are as well even if you don't realize it.

I think as we evaluate the state of AI (shout out to my 'State of AI' series), it's really important to consider questions like:

  1. Does AI have 'taste'? Can it accurately express your 'taste'?
  2. How is 'taste' changing? How is AI changing this directly or indirectly?
  3. What even is good 'taste' anymore? Or generally just 'good'???

Let's get into it.

Who Cares?

Who Cares

Honestly it's a fair question.

When you talk about taste, often people - including myself - think of it as a pretty loose thing. More often than not, related to clothing and style specifically, and while that is a very real and visceral display of one's taste it's just one expression.

To me, taste is everything.

If you want to improve something, you need to be able to imagine something better.

That's what taste is. Can you look at something and say that it's good or bad? Do you have clear reasons for why? That's taste.

Being able to identify an issue, pick out specifically what's wrong with it and come up with a solution requires a lot of skills (especially depending on domain) but it all starts with having good taste.

I haven't thought about this a lot until recently, but I realized this has always affected me as I've always been told I have 'weird' taste.

This is one of the reasons I think this is tough to talk about, because taste is so subjective. There's no 'right' or 'wrong' so it's hard for us to evaluate 'good taste' or 'bad taste' objectively.

Many use this as an excuse to discredit one's taste - as if there were an objective 'good taste' that some have and others don't.

One of my favorite podcasts - Cortex with CGP Grey - has a great episode on this topic where he talks about why he values taste and I think it's super well said. Aptly in the episode titled "Being Better".

Taste In The Age Of The Internet

Internet Taste

I won't spend too much time on this part but I think it's worth acknowledging how the internet has impacted taste and more broadly culture over the last few decades.

In some ways it feels subtle but in others - as an older 20 something - it's so evident and honestly overwhelming how much the internet has 'standardized' culture.

I think a valid critique of this would be that this is mostly the internet world, not the real world. While I think that's at least a bit true, I think it's much more true that the internet world and the real world are closer than ever.

To say, I think it's interesting to see how people of all ages and walks of life have slowly all begun to use the same memes, slang, etc. in a way that's kind of cool yet also a bit weird?

Maybe the real issue though is that to me at least, it feels like the internet has really lost its own taste but that's another topic...

Taste In The Age Of AI (Dead Internet Theory?)

The internet's homogenization of taste feels like just the beginning when we look at AI's potential impact.

I've been thinking about this a lot, especially in the context of "Dead Internet Theory" - I won't talk about that more don't worry but I do think these are pretty related topics. How can they not be?

There's a pretty interesting study (https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07462) that shows how our language online is becoming more homogenized. We're using similar words more frequently, reducing what researchers call "lexical richness." It's like we're all slowly converging on a shared, simplified vocabulary. While this might make communication more efficient, it's also making it more... boring.

I think this is kind of one symptom showing why taste will become more important than ever.

And it goes well beyond just writing right - eventually music, art ("AI art"), software, everything will be influenced by all this. How does that influence our collective taste?

As generative AI becomes more prevalent in content creation, having strong, well-developed taste will be what separates authentic human expression from AI-generated content. It's not just about being different for the sake of being different - it's about maintaining genuine human perspective and judgment in a world where everything is becoming increasingly standardized.

Another podcast plug - great Ezra Klein episode about this.

Conclusion

So what's the point of this? A goofy tirade about how no one has unique thoughts anymore?

Partially. But mostly no.

My point here is that in a world where everyone is at least a little worried about being replaced by AI and everything seems so nihilistic, I think it's important to remember that the unlimited generation machine is not always perfect.

I think it's important to keep in mind as we continue to use AI, develop new models and products and lord knows what. We need to be mindful of the influences these awesome technologies have on our ourselves - even beyond our tastes! There's a whole discussion to be had about how Cursor is affecting my laziness as a developer.

Both for our sanity and our ability to make things that are actually good and not just more AI slop.

AI Slop

Comments

No comments available :/

Leave your thoughts! 💭


Tags

Gen AI

ML/AI

State of AI (Early 2025)

Say hi!